An Observation about Realism and Abstraction


I'm posting two small, exercise paintings, with no judgement as to whether they are "good" or "bad". What I do want to comment about is how we engage differently with the realistic painting versus the abstraction.
It is so easy to critique the realistic piece, because we judge it based on the images we have in our personal visual vocabulary of a waterfall (the water doesn't look right, the landscape area looks weak, and the Moon is too small). We see the piece as a whole first, but then we pick apart the areas that don't appeal to us. We make our final evaluation of the work with what we think a waterfall should look like.
Now we encounter the abstraction. The first reaction is "what is it?". The viewer immediately sees the image as a whole, and makes an immediate judgement whether they like it or not, often based on the colors. It is difficult to pick out those failed individual areas, because there is little reference to realism. So, the viewer always sees the work as a whole, making their judgement of the work without critiquing individual passages.
Look at these two exercise paintings. Do you "see" them differently?
Leave a Comment